A Tale of Two New Launches: How Pine Grove is Undergoing a Renaissance

Pine Grove is a private residential estate located in the Ulu Pandan neighbourhood, in the Rest of Central Region (RCR) district 21. The estate was initially populated by landed houses, before condominiums started being built there in the 1970’s.

In 1977, Ridgewood Condominium was built next to the site of the Singapore American School, with Pandan Valley following in 1981. To this day, these condos are still popular and enjoy price growth, with resale prices of condos showing a 39% median price growth across the past decade.

One of the key reasons why homebuyers are drawn towards the Pine Grove estate is its exclusivity. Pine Grove is a low-density private enclave, and is elevated overlooking the surrounding greenery of Clementi Forest, and the low rise Holland Road estate.

What’s There in the Private Housing Market?

Pine Grove has been an established private housing estate for almost 50 years. Many of the condos there are getting old – in fact only 4 out of the 15 condos in the Pine Grove area have been launched after 2000.

Table 1 and Image 1: Condos around Pine Grove

Source: ERA Research and Market Intelligence

With no new launches in the area past 2013, the private property market in Ulu Pandan has seen lukewarm activity. This can be attributed to a variety of reasons, such as a reluctance/lack of urgency on the part of homeowners to sell their home, as they might encounter difficulty in finding a replacement home in the same area. This applies to both condo owners, as well as landed homeowners that might be looking to right-size.

A Tale of Two New Launches

However, in recent years, we saw the sale of two land parcels at Pine Grove, which is set to rejuvenate the quiet private housing market there, riding on the back of the HDB developments in nearby Ulu Pandan.

In 2022, Pine Grove GLS Parcel A saw a competitive bidding process which saw five developers particpating. Ultimately, it was awarded to a joint venture between UOL and Singapore Land Group who edged out the others by a razor-thin margin of $800 – talk about an exciting narrative!

Fast forward to a 2023 where the eventual project was launched as Pinetree Hill, a 520-unit high-rise condominium. As of October 2024, Pinetree Hill has sold about 72% of its units slightly a year after its launch.

In November, we can expect to see the launch of a second condominium at Pine Grove, named Nava Grove. The development will be built upon the Pine Grove Parcel B GLS site, which was awarded in late 2023 to a joint venture between Sinarmas Land and MCL Land. The highest of three bids placed on the site amounted to about $1,223 psf ppr, about 7.2% lower than that of Pine Grove Parcel A.

So, what makes this pair of projects worth talking about?

Fantastic RCR Location

Both of them sit in D21 in the RCR, but if you take out your pencils and rulers, and start to draw out the planning region boundaries, you would find that they sit literally one road away from the prestigious Core Central Region (CCR).

The estate is also located near great amenities in the nearby areas of Ghim Moh, which has a market and food centre, as well as Holland Village, with shops, a mall, and food centres.

Image 2: Location of Pinetree Hill and Nava Grove

This means that the projects essentially benefit from a CCR location, at an RCR price tag. The Pan Island (PIE) and Ayer Rajah (AYE) Expressways are located 5 minutes away, which connects residents to various commercial and industrial hubs across the country.

The AYE provides a 15-minute drive to the Central Business District, while the Orchard Road district is also accessible via a direct route down Holland Road, reachable in 10-12 minutes.

One-north, another major business district is less than 10 minutes away – one of the most attractive qualities of the development’s location.

Proximity to Henry Park Primary School

Both developments will be situated in 2km of Henry Park Primary School, one of the most prestigious and well-known primary schools in Singapore. It is widely known that families will intentionally move to the Pine Grove, Ghim Moh, and Holland Road neighbourhoods to live near this school.

Being located within a short distance of these schools makes these two projects attractive, a characteristic that is likely to translate well in the resale market.

Attractive Entry Prices and Good Potential Price Growth

The pricing of these two projects is generally safe, compared to other recent RCR projects.

Chart 1: Price ($psf) comparison of new projects in various RCR regions

Source: URA as of 16 Oct 2024, ERA Research and Market Intelligence

The closest comparison on the market currently would be 8@BT, also within D21 in the RCR. Since its launch in late September, 8@BT has transacted at a median price of $2,737psf, compared to Pinetree Hill which has transacted at a median price of $2,453psf since its launch.

Nearby HDB Developments

In 2022, the HDB had announced a plan to develop three housing projects, totalling around 3,000 BTO flats to further develop and rejuvenate the areas surrounding Dover MRT.

These developments will take place directly south of the Pine Grove neighbourhood, and create additional amenities not too far away that residents can enjoy.

Image 3: HDB developments nearby at Dover

In addition to this, after these BTO flats complete their minimum occupation period, their homeowners could look to upgrade and live in the Pine Grove estate. With Pinetree Hill and Nava Grove being the newest projects on the market, and in the vicinity of Henry Park Primary School, these HDB upgraders could be a valuable exit strategy.

With these two projects standing side-by-side, what are the differences between the projects, and more importantly – which should you choose?

Completion Timeframe

With Pinetree Hill launching earlier than Nava Grove, it is highly likely that the project will meet TOP and be completed earlier, allowing you to move in to your new home faster.

Pinetree Hill has an expected TOP in 2027, while Nava Grove has an expected TOP in 2028 – although anticipated completion could fall earlier.

Harmonisation of Gross Floor Area (GFA)

Another key difference between the two projects would be how the harmonisation of GFA affects their pricing and unit layouts. Nava Grove, tendered after the GFA harmonisation would see higher prices per square foot, and will feature more efficient designs.

At the end of the day, whichever your choice might be, there isn’t really a wrong move buying into an established RCR estate like Pine Grove.

Whether your reason to buy your property is for own-stay or investment, the coveted RCR location combined with the development of the surrounding estate and make prospects look promising.

Disclaimer

This information is provided solely on a goodwill basis and does not relieve parties of their responsibility to verify the information from the relevant sources and/or seek appropriate advice from relevant professionals such as valuers, financial advisers, bankers and lawyers. For avoidance of doubt, ERA Realty Network and its salesperson accepts no responsibility for the accuracy, reliability and/or completeness of the information provided. Copyright in this publication is owned by ERA and this publication may not be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, in whole or in part, without prior written approval.